9 in 10 universities are restricting free speech

24 February 2017

9 in 10 UK universities are now restricting free speech in some way, according to a survey by online magazine Spiked.

Almost two thirds (63.5%) now actively censor speech, and 30.5% stifle speech through excessive regulation, indicating a steady rise in censorship over the past three years.

Only 6% of universities have not imposed any censorship on their students.

Andrea Williams, Chief Executive of Christian Concern, said that Christians must stand with those under attack for speaking truth, continue to speak the truth about Jesus themselves.

How does the survey work?

The Free Speech University Rankings (FSUR), issued by Spiked, covers policies and bans relating to all types of free expression, from both university administrations and student unions.

This includes what students can say, what publications, songs or adverts they can engage with and which speakers they can to invite to campus.

It also covers “policies and actions that constitute thought reform, such as mandatory conduct classes and policies that require students to say certain things”, according to Spiked.

The survey categorised the universities into a traffic light system.

1 in 4 university administrations ‘hostile’ to free speech

Universities branded ‘red’ banned and actively censored ideas on campus, while ‘amber’ universities ‘chilled’ free speech through intervention.

Almost a quarter (23.5%) of university administrations were branded ‘red’, a 15% increase from last year.

According to the survey, these universities are “hostile to free speech and free expression, mandating explicit restrictions on speech, including, but not limited to, bans on specific ideologies, political affiliations, beliefs, books, speakers or words”.

64% of student unions were branded ‘red’.

However, 16 were given ‘green’ ratings (meaning they have not restricted or regulated speech and expression in any way) – compared with 12 university administrations.

44% had ‘no-platform policies’

There were 129 bans among institutions’ actions that the survey considered restrictive.

This included 21 institutions that banned speakers and 20 that banned newspapers.

44% of institutions had ‘no-platform policies’ that banned ‘fascist, racist and Islamist groups’. 43% had censorious ‘religion and belief policies’, and 34% had restrictive ‘transgender’ policies.

The rise in censorship

Taking administration and students’ unions as a whole, 73 institutions were branded ‘red’, and 35 were branded ‘amber’.

Several of those branded ‘red’ this year had been branded ‘amber’ in last year’s survey, while some branded ‘amber’ this year had been ‘green’ last year.

‘Illiberal, patronising outlook’

Tom Slater, co-ordinator of FSUR, commented: “Students’ unions have been pilloried for censoring ‘transphobic’ speech and enforcing transgender pronouns. But our research shows the vast majority of policies in this area stem from universities themselves.

“While students’ unions are significantly more censorious – and deserve all the criticism they get – universities often share and affirm their illiberal, patronising outlook.”

‘Stand with those who are being censored’

Commenting on the findings, Andrea Williams emphasised the need for believers to “stand with those who are being censored”:

“It’s extraordinary to think that it was ten years ago that the Christian Legal Centre were involved in the Christian Union at Exeter [University] being removed from the campus because Exeter Students’ Union said its policies were discriminatory… Why? Because people… had to sign a statement of faith, and that discriminated against non-believers.

“Where truth is under attack, where people are being censored, we need to stand with those who are being censored.”

Last year, a student at the University of Sheffield was removed from his social work course for expressing the biblical view of marriage on his own Facebook page. Felix Ngole is being supported by the Christian Legal Centre as he challenges the removal from his course.

  • Share

Related articles

All content has been loaded.

Take action

Join our email list to receive the latest updates for prayer and action.

Find out more about the legal support we're giving Christians.

Help us put the hope of Jesus at the heart of society.

Privacy settings

Our website uses cookies, usage analysis and other technologies. We use these tools because they help us to run our website, provide you with content (including video and audio clips), understand how people use our website, make improvements to our services, and promote our work more effectively. This means that we and selected third-party services may store cookies and other similar information on your device, and may analyse how you use our website. Some of these tools are necessary for our website to function as intended but others are optional, and you can choose whether or not to allow them. You can find out more here.

Core functionality

Certain cookies and other technologies are used on our website to provide core functionality. You can read more about this here. You may be able to use your browser settings to block these tools but if you do, our website may not function as intended.

Embedded content

To enrich your experience of this website, we embed carefully selected content from other platforms. For example, we embed video clips from our YouTube channel, and audio clips from our SoundCloud channel. These third-party platforms may store and use cookies (or similar technology) on your device, and may analyse your use of this site or the embedded content. We do not directly control what technologies they use. You can find out more here. If embedded content is disabled it may affect your experience of this website.

Analytics and promotion

This website uses tools from selected third-party providers (Google and Facebook) to help us understand how people arrive at and use our website, and to measure and improve the effectiveness of some of our promotional activity. These tools may store and use cookies (and similar information) on your device, and analyse your use of this website, and other sites and platforms. These tools help us to improve our services, reach people who may be interested in our work and make better use of our resources but information may be shared with these third-party providers and may be used for their own purposes. You can find out more here.