Press Release

Archie: European Court of Human Rights rejects families’ application

3 August 2022         Issued by: Christian Concern

This evening, the European Court of Humans Rights (ECHR) has rejected the urgent legal application from the parents of 12-year-old Archie Battersbee. In a letter to the family and their legal team, the letter said: “We regret to inform you that on 3 August 2022 the President of the Court decided not to indicate to the Government of the United Kingdom, under Rule 39 of the Rules of Court, the interim measure you are seeking. Therefore the Court will not interfere with the decisions of the national courts to allow the withdrawal of life sustaining treatment from Archie Battersbee to proceed.” The family have had offers from doctors in Japan and Italy to treat Archie and are now considering their options. Responding to the news, Archie’s mum, Hollie Dance, said: “This is another heart-breaking development in our fight for Archie’s right to live. We have been contacted by doctors in Japan and Italy who say they are willing to treat Archie, why can’t we give him a chance? “The NHS, the government and the Courts in this country and Europe may have given up on treating him, but we have not.“The whole system has been stacked against us. Reform must now come through Charlie’s Law so that no parents have to go through this.  “In a worst-case scenario, we want to take Archie to a hospice, but the hospital have said that we cannot do that despite previous promises. We have been told all along that this is all about Archie dying with ‘dignity’, and yet we are told we cannot take him to a hospice where it is quiet and we can spend time with him as a family without the chaos at the hospital. “We will fight to end for Archie’s right to live.” This morning, just before the 9am deadline set by Barts Health NHS Trust, the families’ lawyers submitted an application to the ECHR based on a complaint about the United Kingdom’s refusal to honour the UN interim measures which stated that Archie’s life-support should not be removed. The application concerned the events of 29 July – 2 August 2022, especially the refusal of the United Kingdom government’s Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, Barts Health NHS Trust and Royal London Hospital and the domestic courts to honour the Interim Measures indicated by the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UN CRPD) on 29 July. The family said that this refusal failed to honour the UN CRPD Interim Measures and constituted a separate violation of international law, including the European Convention of Human Rights. The UK courts have taken the view that UN CRPD Interim Measures have a different status in UK domestic law from ECHR Interim Measures, because ECHR rights are incorporated in domestic UK law whereas the terms of the relevant UN Convention are not so incorporated. Lawyers argued that in these circumstances, it would be appropriate for the Court to indicate Interim Measures in similar terms to those indicated by the UN CRPD. The application sought the following interim measures: ‘a prohibition on the Royal London Hospital (which is part of the United Kingdom National Health Service and an emanation of the State) to withdraw life-preserving medical treatment (including mechanical ventilation and artificial nutrition and hydration) from Archie Battersbee pending determination of the substantive application.’ In submissions, lawyers identified that the hospital Trust has confirmed in domestic proceedings that the decisions to withdraw treatment and to do so urgently are not in any way influenced by any need to save resources. Therefore, lawyers argued that the Interim Measures pending determination of the substantive application would not cause any real harm or prejudice. Andrea Williams, chief executive of the Christian Legal Centre, said: “This is a story about a mother’s love. She was catapulted into a whirlwind of legal battles and media attention all because she believed in giving her beloved son more time.  “Even though the whole system has come against her she has stood with her legal team against all the odds. “The hospital and courts say this is all about Archie’s dignity which means he should die quickly and at a specified time. The parents don’t agree that it is dignified and in his best interests to die. Even the parents’ request to move him to a hospice is being denied as undignified. “Common humanity requires a different way of doing this. “We continue to stand with the family as they consider their next options.”

  • Share
Privacy settings

Our website uses cookies, usage analysis and other technologies. We use these tools because they help us to run our website, provide you with content (including video and audio clips), understand how people use our website, make improvements to our services, and promote our work more effectively. This means that we and selected third-party services may store cookies and other similar information on your device, and may analyse how you use our website. Some of these tools are necessary for our website to function as intended but others are optional, and you can choose whether or not to allow them. You can find out more here.

Core functionality

Certain cookies and other technologies are used on our website to provide core functionality. You can read more about this here. You may be able to use your browser settings to block these tools but if you do, our website may not function as intended.

Embedded content

To enrich your experience of this website, we embed carefully selected content from other platforms. For example, we embed video clips from our YouTube channel, and audio clips from our SoundCloud channel. These third-party platforms may store and use cookies (or similar technology) on your device, and may analyse your use of this site or the embedded content. We do not directly control what technologies they use. You can find out more here. If embedded content is disabled it may affect your experience of this website.

Analytics and promotion

This website uses tools from selected third-party providers (Google and Facebook) to help us understand how people arrive at and use our website, and to measure and improve the effectiveness of some of our promotional activity. These tools may store and use cookies (and similar information) on your device, and analyse your use of this website, and other sites and platforms. These tools help us to improve our services, reach people who may be interested in our work and make better use of our resources but information may be shared with these third-party providers and may be used for their own purposes. You can find out more here.