“Dr A” raised concerns about bearded male patients who identify as women being placed on female-only psychiatric wards. Instead of addressing her objections, her NHS Trust turned on her for simply pointing out the reality of biological sex.
What’s at stake?
- Medical professionals should not be discriminated against for acting in accordance with biological reality.
- Biologically male staff members, who identify as women, could be put forward to provide intimate same sex care to female patients.
- NHS Trust’s Sexual Safety Policy could result in an assault by a biological man who identifies as a woman being recorded as female-on-female violence, preventing accurate monitoring and scrutiny.
Support Dr A
Dr A is receiving help from the Christian Legal Centre to take her case forwards.
We provide this support completely free of charge to Dr A and others like her.
Make a donation today to help this work continue.
Timeline:
2023
- Throughout the year Dr A raises concerns that the Trust’s policies compromise the safety, dignity, and privacy of female patients and staff.
- October: The Trust’s Delivering Single-Sex Accommodation policy is last updated, stating transgender patients should be accommodated according to their presentation, explicitly applying to toilet and bathing facilities.
2024
- January: Dr A emails the Trust’s Head of EDI with a formal complaint about “factually incorrect and misleading” mandatory training.
- Six weeks later: Dr A chases up the complaint via email. The Head of EDI receives the emails but never responds.
2025
- 16 April: The Supreme Court unanimously rules that “sex”, “woman”, and “man” in the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex.
- 17 April: The Trust reportedly tells staff there will be no immediate changes for patients.
- May: Dr A raises concerns about using women’s toilets at Trust HQ. A senior colleague offers to guard the entrance; Dr A finds this offensive and is advised to use gender-neutral toilets instead.
- June: Dr A lodges a formal grievance over the Trust’s alleged failure to implement the Supreme Court ruling.
- Autumn: The Trust partially upholds the grievance. The panel recommends reviewing policies, setting timescales, clarifying the distinction between sex and gender, and reviewing the Transitioning at Work policy.
2026
- Early in the year: The Trust largely dismisses Dr A’s appeal but agrees to some actions, including a Trust-wide statement on facilities, explanatory notes for policies, and clearer toilet provision information. It declines to set firm deadlines for wider policy review.
- 6 August: Dr A alleges that most agreed actions remain outstanding, with no Trust-wide statement issued and no key policies revised.
- 12 August: The Delivering Single-Sex Accommodation policy remains unchanged.
Videos and media coverage
- Christian Concern Press Release – Legal action launched after NHS Trust allowed bearded male patients who identify as women onto female psychiatric wards
- BBC – Doctor ‘enraged’ over NHS transgender ward policy
- The Times – ‘Bearded trans patient on women’s psychiatric ward exposed himself’
- The Telegraph – Bearded trans patient ‘exposes himself on women’s psychiatric ward’
- GB News – “I’m anonymous because I fear for my safety” Dr A on Free Speech Nation on Sunday night
- TalkTV – An NHS Trust is facing legal action after allowing bearded male patients who identify as women to be admitted to female psychiatric wards
- Conservative Post – Legal action launched after NHS Trust allowed bearded male patients who identify as women onto female psychiatric wards
- The Herald – Doctor begins legal action after patient ‘exposed himself’
Support Dr A
Dr A is receiving help from the Christian Legal Centre to take her case forwards.
We provide this support completely free of charge to Dr A and others like her.
Make a donation today to help this work continue.