A Maltese Christian who endured more than three years of criminal proceedings after speaking publicly about his faith and leaving a homosexual lifestyle has urged European leaders not to reproduce Malta’s controversial “conversion practices” law across the continent.
The speakers addressed Members of the European Parliament in Brussels this week after Matthew Grech was acquitted in what is believed to have been the world’s first criminal trial for “advertising conversion practices”.
Speaking at an event entitled Protecting Freedom of Speech in the Context of “Conversion Practices” Legislation in Europe, the speakers warned that vaguely drafted bans risk criminalising personal testimony, pastoral ministry and the freedom of adults to seek counselling consistent with their own goals and beliefs.
Voices Not Yet Heard
The collaborative event hosted by MEP Paolo Inselvini and Core Issues Trust also drew speakers from the United Kingdom, Hungary and Italy, platforming stories that are rarely listened to when politicians propose ‘conversion practices’ bans.
Christians shared how their relationship with Jesus Christ – and, in some cases, pastoral care or clinical intervention – led to transformative changes in their feelings and behaviours.
Dr Mike Davidson, the chairman of the International Foundation for Therapeutic and Counselling Choice (IFTCC) and chief executive of Core Issues Trust, said:
“Politicians seldom take the time to listen to those of us who have a positive experience of pastoral support or counselling.
“Our Voices Not Yet Heard campaign seeks to redress that. We are calling on Westminster, Stormont to listen to our stories and experience, and to protect the freedom of others like us to access support.”
Roger Kiska, legal counsel for the Christian Legal Centre which has supported Matthew through his ordeal, also addressed the European Parliament, highlighting how conversion practices bans are incompatible with human rights:
“In Europe we have something called the European Convention on Human Rights, and there are fundamental human rights at stake when it comes to self-fulfilment and identifying how you want to identify.”
The meeting comes as the European Commission prepares to adopt a Recommendation in 2027 calling on all 27 EU Member States to ban so-called “conversion practices”. Malta became the first European country to introduce such a ban in 2016.
Mr Grech was charged following an interview broadcast by PMnews Malta in 2022, during which he described his personal decision to leave behind a homosexual lifestyle after becoming a Christian.
During the interview, he discussed his own experience, the importance of his Christian faith and the availability of both pastoral and professional support for people seeking help with unwanted sexual feelings or behaviours. He also referred to an international organisation that supports freedom of counselling choice, the IFTCC.
Prosecutors alleged that the conversation amounted to the criminal advertising of “conversion practices”.
Mr Grech faced a possible five-month prison sentence and a fine of up to €5,000. Over the following three years, he was required to attend 17 court hearings before the Court of Magistrates in Valletta found him not guilty on 4 March 2026.
The two PMnews Malta journalists who conducted the interview also faced trial, but were also acquitted.
Those addressing the European Parliament warned that the term “conversion practices” is often defined so broadly that legislation can extend far beyond abusive conduct and threaten ordinary conversations between counsellors and clients, parents and children, or pastors and members of their congregations.
They argued that coercive or abusive conduct should be dealt with under existing criminal and safeguarding laws, without creating sweeping new offences that could restrict freedom of religion, freedom of expression and adults’ freedom to seek voluntary support.
Concerns about the breadth of such legislation have also intensified in the United Kingdom. Baroness Hilary Cass, author of the independent review into NHS gender identity services for children and young people, has withdrawn her support for the proposed conversion practices legislation in its current form.
She warned that it was not sufficiently tightly drafted to prevent serious unintended consequences, including the possibility of parents being prosecuted for restricting a child’s access to chest binders or hormones.
Opposition has grown among free-speech campaigners, gender-critical groups, Christians and senior Church of England figures concerned about the potential effect on ordinary pastoral ministry.
The Christian Legal Centre has warned that parents, pastors and counsellors could face complaints, investigations or prosecution for otherwise lawful words and actions.
Speaking in Brussels, Matthew Grech said:
“I spent three years in court for a conversation about my own life. Malta’s law was meant to be a model for Europe, but my case shows where that model leads: to the police, prosecutors and courts deciding which life stories are allowed to be told.
“I came to Brussels to ask MEPs to ensure that what happened to me in Malta does not become the law for every family in Europe.
“People must remain free to share their stories, practise their faith and seek the support they choose, without fearing criminal investigation or prosecution.”
Matthew’s story is not isolated. In 2020, Mike Davidson received abusive calls and messages, and saw Barclays Bank and other service providers close the accounts of Core Issues Trust, not many people were jumping to his defence. With our legal team’s help and a petition we organised signed by over 72,000 people, they reached a settlement of over £20,000.
Speaking about the wider implications of the case, Mike Davidson said:
“Matthew Grech was prosecuted over an interview in which he spoke about his own experience and the value of both clinical and pastoral support. It is outrageous that he spent three years facing criminal proceedings simply for telling his story.
“The IFTCC defends adults’ freedom to seek ethical support and supports those who provide it through training, professional development and a firm commitment to client self-determination.”
Andrea Williams, chief executive of the Christian Legal Centre, said:
“Matthew’s acquittal is welcome, but he should never have been prosecuted. His ordeal is a stark warning to Europe that vague ‘conversion practices’ laws can criminalise personal testimony, Christian ministry and the freedom to seek help. No one should face three years in court simply for telling the truth about their own life.”
Find out more about Matthew GrechJoin our email list to receive the latest updates for prayer and action.
Find out more about the legal support we're giving Christians.
Help us put the hope of Jesus at the heart of society.