Cass initially supported the proposal, even being quoted in the official press release.
But giving evidence to the bill committee hearing on Monday, she said that she does not support the bill in its current form.
She explained that her initial response to the bill was made having only had 15 minutes to look at the legislation. But having had time to think about it, she now says “I unfortunately now don’t think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.”
She cited the example of a parent stopping a child’s pocket money or allowance if they thought they would buy a chest binder or hormones, saying that this could result in prosecution.
I raised this issue with the bill in an article the day after the draft legislation was revealed:
“So a rebellious teenager who starts to identify in a different gender could very easily accuse their parents of abusive conversion practices. Any rules laid down about what goes on in the house, rules about how the teen dresses, even refusing to use a chosen name could be called controlling or coercive words and behaviours.
“Any restrictions or limitations on how the teen uses money can be branded as economic pressure.”
It’s great to see the experts catching up.
Cass is not the only person to revise their opinion on conversion practice bans recently.
While Prime Ministers Theresa May and Boris Johnson were repeating completely unjustified mantras about how terrible ‘conversion therapy’ is, it was tough to find anyone opposed to a ban.
When, in 2020, Mike Davidson received abusive calls and messages, and saw Barclays Bank and other service providers close the accounts of Core Issues Trust, not many people were jumping to his defence. With our legal team’s help and a petition we organised, signed by over 72,000 people, they reached a settlement of over £20,000.
Now, the Telegraph is running a campaign against the bill, as is the Free Speech Union. Several LGB, and gender critical groups are opposed to it.
Christians, who were sometimes a little tentative to put their neck out, are now much bolder to oppose this bill outright. Even senior Church of England leaders are raising concerns about the bill’s effect on normal Christian ministry.
I welcome it all. There is joy in the presence of the angels.
All of these people and groups are right to point out the absurd and dangerous consequences of this badly drafted bill.
It really is a tool to enforce submission to LGBTQ+ ideology. Parents and pastors are at threat for the most reasonable and uncontroversial words and actions.
But those who’ve come to realise this would do well to go a little further and question what they’ve been told about ‘gay conversion therapy’. The same people pushing for prayer bans and gender self-ID now have been misleading everyone about ‘conversion therapy’ for years.
It’s not just parents and pastors who would be unfairly targeted by a ban. The people most often identified as conversion therapy advocates – ministries like the aforementioned Core Issues Trust and the International Foundation for Therapeutic Choice and Counselling Choice provide ample evidence that talking therapy approaches to helping people are safe, ethical and effective. We summed some of this up on our Free to Talk website – talking doesn’t harm.
The problem with the bill isn’t just that it ‘accidentally’ leaves the door open to all kinds of unwanted prosecutions and investigations. It’s also not that, to this day, no one has demonstrated a harmful ‘practice’ that is not already illegal.
The problem is that the whole thing is cooked up, and always was.
This week, Mike Davidson, Matthew Grech and Roger Kiska (Legal Counsel for the Christian Legal Centre) spoke at the European Parliament in Brussels at an event on Protecting Freedom of Speech and Conscience in the light of “Conversion Practices” legislation.
MEPs are willing to listen to them. Will Westminster?
It is mindboggling when you think about how silenced the likes of Mike Davidson and Matthew Grech have been. They can give you articulate explanations of what the studies on talking therapy actually say. They can point to their many resources committing to best practice, ethics and client self-determination. They can give you testimonies of lives changed for good, including their own, through appropriate support.
But how many will platform them and advocate for their freedom of expression? How many will call for the right for someone caught in an unwanted LGBTQ+ lifestyle to work towards their own chosen goals in therapy? Will they get invited to give evidence to the bill committee?
Sure, it’s easier and more convenient to point out the many other failings of this particular bill. It’s fair to describe it as pro-trans madness. It’s right to say that it threatens parents and pastors for completely normal, innocent conversations. We can keep doing that until this bill is comprehensively defeated.
However, we need to see that the whole thing’s smoke and mirrors.
Join our email list to receive the latest updates for prayer and action.
Find out more about the legal support we're giving Christians.
Help us put the hope of Jesus at the heart of society.