Christian preacher manhandled by police, faces trial
22 February 2017 Issued by: Christian Legal CentreA Christian evangelist who was manhandled and arrested by police last year whilst preaching on the streets of Bristol, is to stand trial tomorrow (Thursday 23 February) charged with public order offences.
Michael Overd, will appear at Bristol Magistrates’ Court, alongside two friends, Adrian Clark and Michael Stockwell. The hearing is scheduled to last four days. Charges against a fourth man have been dropped.
During the incident last year (6 July 2016), Mr Overd was forcibly removed from the scene by a police officer. Video evidence from Mr Overd’s bodycam shows him falling to the floor and crying out in pain. Extracts from the video can be viewed here.
‘Challenging Muslims’
The video also records the police officer saying that Mr Overd was “challenging homophobia” (sic) and “challenging Muslims”, to which Mr Overd responds that he and his friends were “just saying what the Bible says”.
The recording goes on to show the police officer asking for advice on whether Mr Overd can be charged with any offences, but only after Mr Overd had been forcibly removed from the scene.
Mr Overd has previously been arrested and stood trial for his street preaching but successfully contested the charges, citing the importance of freedom of speech.
He and his friends have been charged with offences under the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and the Public Order Act 1986.
They are being supported by the Christian Legal Centre and will be represented in court by allied solicitor Michael Phillips.
‘Over the top’
Mr Overd and his three friends were preaching in Bristol’s Broadmead Shopping Centre last year (6 July 2016).
They took it in turns to preach, and as they did so, a crowd gathered. At points, the crowd was loud and aggressive, with some swearing and being abusive towards the men. There was also, however, debate between the preachers and members of the crowd, especially on the differences between Islam and Christian belief. Several hecklers appeared to be supportive of Islam.
Police did not arrive on the scene until about an hour into the preaching. A police officer approached Mr Clark, asking him to turn off his amplification, which he did.
Shortly afterwards a mounted police officer asked Mr Clark to stop preaching so that she could speak to him. Whilst Mr Clark spoke with the officer, Mr Overd took over the preaching.
Soon afterwards, another police officer approached Mr Overd and told him that he was “causing a disturbance” and “not welcome”.
The officer told Mr Overd that he was going to give him a Dispersal Notice. But instead of doing so, he forcibly removed Mr Overd from the scene, despite Mr Overd (who suffers from chronic back pain) crying out in pain.
The officer is later heard asking for advice on whether the men could be charged with offences, saying that Mr Overd has “gone over the top” and “he’s just wound up people”.
Public order offences
Mr Overd and his friends were eventually taken to Patchway Custody Centre, Bristol, held for several hours, and released on police bail to return for questioning.
They were charged under Section 31 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 for using “threatening or abusive words or behaviour or disorderly behaviour within the hearing or sight of a person likely to be caused harassment, alarm or distress, thereby, and the offence was religiously aggravated.”
The charge against one of the men was subsequently dropped, however.
But the remaining three were additionally charged with offences under the Public Order Act 1986.
Mr Overd, Mr Clark and Mr Stockwell will argue that the case raises crucial issues of freedom of speech and freedom of religion. They highlight that they simply explained the Bible’s teaching and sought to respond to questions, comments and objections raised by those in the crowd.
The men say that they cannot and should not distort the plain teaching of the Bible that Jesus is God’s Son and the only way to God.
Given that much of the debate centred on objections to their teaching about key differences between Islam and Christianity, the men have submitted a report from an expert witness, highlighting that their explanation reflects what the Bible and Qur’an say.
‘Offence is subjective’
Andrea Williams, chief executive of the Christian Legal Centre said:
“Mr Overd and his friends are motivated by love. They want to share the good news of Jesus with people who might not otherwise hear it. Sometimes that means addressing the false claims of other religions or ideologies. Robust debate is sometimes necessary, especially when objections are being raised or abuse hurled. We shouldn’t be afraid of it.
“The aggressive treatment of Mr Overd and his friends by the police and prosecution is shocking. The police should be defending freedom of speech, not clamping down on it.
“‘Offence’ is a very subjective thing and is easily manipulated to shut down viewpoints that people simply don’t like. Any suggestion that there is a right not to be offended must be strongly resisted. In today’s democracy, we need the freedom to debate, challenge and disagree.
“But this was not just an attack on freedom of speech but an abuse of power. We will not only be seeking the acquittal of these Christian men but seeking an apology from the Chief Constable of Avon and Somerset police, compensation and assurances that officers are better trained to protect freedom of expression.”
Notes for editors
Extracts of video showing arrest:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8tMZE5UvNLg
Video featuring Michael Overd:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0Nmfnf0yEY
